Category: Reviews

  • The Remarkable Retirement of Edna Fisher

    The Remarkable Retirement of Edna Fisher

    Now that I am elderly myself (In internet years) I am really enjoying these stories that have older people with health issues going on adventures, and couldn’t resist a chosen one story with a little old lady at the helm.

    The story follows Edna, a woman in a home for the elderly who is visited by a wizard who is very unhappy to tell her that she is the chosen one to stop an evil wizard who controls dragons from continuing to take out the Knights. As we travel the modern magical world with Edna, she assembles her party and slowly comes to realize that not all is what it seems with this quest or the Knights as an organization.

    It is such a fun read—Fast paced and it reads very much like a young adult novel despite the elderly protagonist. Edna is lovely and comes in with a wealth of life experiences, and never feels like she is suddenly much younger or more capable than someone her age might be, and it is a lot of fun to watch her both mentor the young people who surround her and find a way around physical challenges using her life experiences.

    There is a predictability to the book, though, if you are familiar with the tropes introduced in the story. None of the twists came as a surprise, which was fine by me but if you are a reader that requires surprise you may be disappointed.

    Overall, I think this will be one of my favourites for the year. It’s a unique take on an old classic, with a lot of fun world building and a very nontraditional ending for this kind of story. If you’re looking for a light read with some surprisingly heavy themes, this is definitely worth picking up.

  • Brain Camp review

    Brain Camp review

    I missed reading, but also I was having trouble finding a book. I kept dropping them, bit found something with Faith Hick’s name on it that I hadn’t read yet and, well, I was a comic person for a very long time so might as well!

    The story follows two misfits who are sent to a summer camp. Jenna is the outcast in a family of very smart people while Lucas is a delinquent. They are both invited to an exclusive camp that produces geniuses and their parents ship them off. Once they get there, though, they start to notice that something isn’t right about the camp, that people’s personalities disappear when they become suddenly brilliant, and other campers are going missing. Once they learn more, they decide they need to escape.

    This was such a fun read for October especially. I love the art, but the story with these two kids is great in that they make mistakes that make sense, make the wrong choices at times, and doesn’t make them mini adults who seem to be wise well beyond their years. It really leans into these kids being kids and approaching this bizarre situation like kids.

    I also really loved the ending. Not to spoil anything (For once) but the fact that there are lasting consequences to the story that they are taking advantage of makes the story feel more impactful and that some people in the story face no repercussions is a nice dose of reality, even if it’s a little sad.

    Overall, I loved it! Highly recommend if you are looking for a YA graphic novel/comic book. It’s quick, a little spooky, and the secret of what was really happening was genuinely surprising. It was a blast.

  • Boy, Snow, Bird review

    Boy, Snow, Bird review

    Finally, I went into the book having read the blurb so I knew what I was getting into! Unfortunately, the blurb seems to have been written for a different book than the one I read. Maybe the author didn’t get any say in it? Who knows.

    This is essentially three different books. In the first, we follow a woman named Boy as she escapes her abusive father and makes a new life for herself in Flax Hill, settling for safety and security over anything that she has any real love for and deciding that this is the way it should be. In the second we follow Bird, who is Boy’s biological daughter as we encounter themes of race and watch as she communicates with the sister that Boy sent away before meeting her and coming to understand why her mother distrusts her even if she’s not sure it’s fair. Finally, the third has us snap back to Boy as she discovers that her father is a traumatized transman and biologically her mother and then decides to bring both of the girls with her on a quest to detransition her father and the story stops before anything more happens.

    It’s an incredibly meandering read. Though I found Boy interesting, she doesn’t want anything and this is very much a book where things happen more than a story is told. There’s very little chemistry between characters, and I’m not sure if the flat characterization of so many of the characters is a result of Boy’s indifference to everything or if the depth just wasn’t there.

    Also that last part. The book really does stop rather than end, and the last third really does come completely out of nowhere. It’s a very sour end to a dull read. I don’t typically spoil stories like this, or I try not to, but in this instance I think it’s necessary for readers to know what’s coming there.

    Overall, I was definitely not the audience for this one. I think it’s literary fiction, which is likely a better fit for someone else.

  • Rest is Resistance review

    Rest is Resistance review

    Today is another lesson in I need to actually read the description. Actually, in this case I need to read the full title because this did not end up being what I expected.

    Rest is Resistance reads like someone’s stream of consciousness thoughts connecting naps to black liberation. The writing is very repetitive and felt like it could have been edited down into an essay that was more impactful with how often it revisited the same points in the same ways.

    I can fully acknowledge that this book is not for me. Though I am a woman of colour, I am not black. I also don’t have the spiritual context to understand some of the ideas and it seems to be framed in some kind of Christianity. I am very familiar with capitalism and grind culture, but I am not entirely sure what the author means by these concepts as they are repeated over and over again without discussing why they are a problem or even defining what is encompassed in these terms. Outside of the title, I’m not really sure what else I was meant to take from the book.

    Overall, not my thing. I was not the audience for this, but maybe you are.

  • Wintering review

    Wintering review

    Every time I think I’m improving, I seem to fall back. Which isn’t that bad when you have a read that feels a lot like the author is currently going through the exact same thing.

    The book is an autobiographical look at the author’s own journey as she finds herself getting sick and learning to scale back and enter a “wintering” phase of her life. It’s written in a stream of consciousness kind of way, where we move from thought to thought with the themes holding the chapters together.

    And right now, the meandering feel of it really worked for me. It seemed like her journey of poor health and recovery was a lot more straightforward and quick than anything I’m going through, but I could find myself relating to a lot of the thoughts and feelings of loss of your old life and having to learn to take it easy when you used to do everything.

    I don’t know if this book is for everyone, but it was a nice one for me, especially at this time of my life where I am very much also in a wintering phase. It might be good for you if you are in one, or if you know someone currently having to remove and rest.

  • Piranesi review

    Piranesi review

    Reading may be going very slowly as a result of the heat wave and also just generally being tired, but I have heard such good things about this that I did my best to make sure I could enjoy this one. And hopefully I can start getting back into the swing of things!

    We follow a young man who lives in a strange house full of rooms with statues. As far as he knows, this house is the whole world and he is on a quest for knowledge, working with a man who appears for regular meetings twice a week called The Other. Slowly, he realizes that not only is The Other not who he appears, but he is not the person he thinks he might be either.

    This is exactly my kind of book. The narrator is unreliable not because he is actively lying but because he is in a perspective that has been manipulated and lied to. There’s a strange other world where the worldbuilding is light and not fully explained, letting a lot of questions and mysteries continue to exist throughout that do not ultimately matter to the plot, but are fun to fill in on your own.

    The framing device of the journals is interesting, but it does highlight what I think might be a thing people may have trouble with: The voice of the lead. He does come across innocent and naive, which can be frustrating for some people but I really liked it given the context it was presented in.

    Overall, really loved it! If you get the chance to read it, I would highly recommend it. It’s one of the few times I really like an award winning book, but it had to happen again at some point!

  • Murder Your Employer review

    Murder Your Employer review

    I’m slowly getting used to the idea that I cannot devour books like I used to. Then again, sometimes you get a book that is good enough that the crash is worth it.

    The book follows three people who are brought to a very special school. Everyone there is an adult who has a singular goal: Murder. Each and every student has someone that they want to eliminate in the world, a person whose death would ultimately make the world a better place and there is no other resolution to their existence. The first half of the book is primarily about the school and how they train people. The second half has us follow three of the students as they carry out the murder.

    I loved this book. It took a while to really get into, since the world building was very heavy in the first half. Once we’re out in the world and seeing them apply their skills for their particular target and you see just how terrible their actual targets are to warrant this kind of action, it ends up feeling very cathartic and fun to watch things unfold. Also, Doris is amazing and I loved her.

    My main issue was with one of the protagonists. There is a woman who is highly skilled, but not that driven to actually do the murder. Once I saw more of her perspective, I was more annoyed than rooting for her and ultimately didn’t care about what happened. I would much rather read someone who is driven without the skills than skillful without the drive.

    It was ultimately a fantastic read. I had so much fun with it and hope that the ending was a fake out because I do not want that one character to meet their end. If you’re in the mood for some 50s style heist-y revenge stories or a school story that’s more college than high school, definitely check it out!

  • Remarkably Bright Creatures review

    Remarkably Bright Creatures review

    After a surprisingly long time of not being able to read (Yay chronic fatigue and brain fog) I pulled myself together to finally get through my latest library hold before I was put back on a several month long waitlist. Something cute, light, and featuring an octopus.

    The story primarily follows Tova, the old woman who cleans the aquarium and is watching as the other elderly people she is friends with move on with their lives and confides in the octopus at the aquarium that she is still struggling with the death of her son from decades ago. Slowly, she learns that her son has not completely vanished from her life and has left behind a secret that she was not expecting to find.

    It is a really cute story, and particularly entertaining interspersed with the perspective of an octopus who does not understand why these dumb humans can’t see the obvious right in front of them. The perspective of Marcellus, who is constantly escaping his tank and trying to make the most of his final days of life and captivity is a lot of fun and honestly the best part of this book.

    The other perspectives I had a harder time with. I honestly didn’t really care about them as characters. Cameron in particular was a very frustrating read given that most of the misunderstandings in the story revolve around him and many of his problems were self inflicted. When things do eventually turn around for him, it doesn’t feel like it was earned or that he changed, just that it was narratively appropriate for it to happen, which was disappointing.

    Overall, though, it was really cute and a fun read. Marcellus is lovely, Tova is endearing, and maybe just skim over Cameron’s chapters if self pitying characters aren’t your thing.

  • We Have Always Lived in the Castle review

    We Have Always Lived in the Castle review

    Back to some fiction and one of those books that I’m pretty sure I got on concept and title alone. I may have heard someone say something about it and it really does sound right up my alley from the concept alone.

    We follow [name], a young woman who is the only one of her family to ever leave the house. She goes into town where everyone knows the story of what happened to her and her family. One night, all but three of them died of a poisoning from dinner, which somehow turned the whole town against them. She is a strange girl herself, having grown up believing in practical magic and practicing it by casting small spells around the property. All seems calm until a distant family member, their cousin [name], shows up one day looking for the family fortune and causing their strange lives to come crumbling down.

    This story reads like a fairy tale, with [name] being very matter of fact about everything that is happening around her, even if she is describing something that seems ridiculous. The people are not so much real people as a single character trait that is brought to the forefront and there doesn’t seem to be that much motivation behind most of the actions of the characters.

    Not that this is a bad thing! It was very much a fun read and interesting to be in the head of someone who was looking through the lens of magical happenings. Overall, I was very entertained, but it really does read more like an old fable with a lesson to be learned. What that lesson is, I’m not sure, but it might be something that you like!

  • Breath review

    Breath review

    For the first time in what feels like ages, I have read a book that I actually sought out intentionally! A lot of people with Long Covid have recommended the book as something to help with the breathwork and tangentially the lowering heart rate stuff that we need to do for recovery.

    The book follows a journalist as he tries to uncover the best ways to breathe and how we have evolved to not breathe as well as we have in the past. There are some interesting insights, but the conclusions he draws seem to be the easiest ones that don’t take into account how the rest of society changed, including working conditions and environmental factors.

    Honestly, it’s about 10% really useful information and the rest is theories that don’t really pan out under scrutiny. Some of the ideas are good and I have been able to incorporate them, such as breathing more through the nose and some of the breathing methods, but a lot of the research feels like it was done for an article meant to get clicks based on the title.

    Overall, maybe skip to the end and the bit about what you should take away from the book. The rest is interesting enough, but ultimately it isn’t that useful beyond those concrete tips that are offered at the end.